metabolism

The 5 Biggest Metabolism Myths Women Still Believe

The 5 Biggest Metabolism Myths Women Still Believe

The 5 Biggest Metabolism Myths Women Still Believe

If you’ve ever thought “my metabolism is broken” or “it’s just my age”, you’re not alone.

Women have been taught a lot of misinformation about metabolism much of it rooted in diet culture, fear-based marketing, and outdated fitness advice. These myths don’t just confuse us; they keep us stuck in cycles of restriction, burnout, and frustration.

Let’s clear the noise and talk about what metabolism actually is and what truly supports it.

Myth #1: “My Metabolism Is Broken”

This is one of the most common beliefs I hear and one of the most harmful.
Your metabolism isn’t broken.
It’s adaptive.
When you chronically under-eat, over-exercise, or live in a constant state of stress, your body adapts by conserving energy. That’s not dysfunction, it’s survival.

What helps instead:
  • Eating enough to support muscle and recovery
  • Strength training regularly
  • Managing stress and sleep
  • Building consistency, not extremes
Your body isn’t working against you.
It’s trying to protect you.

Myth #2: “Eating Less Is the Only Way to Speed Up My Metabolism”

Less food does not equal faster metabolism.
In fact, long-term calorie restriction often leads to:
  • Loss of muscle
  • Lower energy expenditure
  • Increased fatigue
  • Hormonal disruption
Muscle is metabolically active tissue. When you under-eat, your body may sacrifice muscle to conserve energy, slowing your metabolism further.
A stronger metabolism is built by fueling your body well, not starving it.

Myth #3: “Cardio Is the Best Way to Boost Metabolism”

Cardio has benefits but it’s not the metabolic powerhouse it’s often marketed to be.

Endless cardio without strength training can:
  • Increase fatigue
  • Elevate stress hormones
  • Contribute to muscle loss over time
Strength training builds muscle, and muscle supports your metabolism 24/7—not just during workouts.

The most effective approach?
Strength training as your foundation, with cardio as a complement not the main event.

Myth #4: “Your Metabolism Slows Down Dramatically With Age, So It’s Out of Your Control”

Aging itself isn’t the problem.
Muscle loss is.

As women age, muscle naturally declines if we don’t train to maintain it. That loss, not age alone, is what contributes to metabolic slowdown.
The good news?
Muscle can be built at any age.

Strength training:
  • Preserves lean mass
  • Supports bone density
  • Improves insulin sensitivity
  • Enhances energy and independence
Your metabolism isn’t doomed by age, it’s influenced by your habits.

Myth #5: “If the Scale Isn’t Moving, My Metabolism Isn’t Working”

The scale is a very limited tool.

Your metabolism impacts:
  • Energy levels
  • Blood sugar regulation
  • Hormone balance
  • Body composition
  • Strength and recovery
You can be improving metabolically even when the scale stays the same, especially if you’re building muscle while losing fat.

Progress isn’t always lighter.
Sometimes it’s stronger, steadier, and more resilient.

What Actually Supports a Healthy Metabolism

If myths don’t work, what does?
✔ Strength training 2–4x per week
✔ Adequate protein and overall fuel
✔ Consistent movement, not extremes
✔ Sleep and recovery
✔ Stress management
✔ Patience and long-term thinking
Metabolism isn’t something you “hack.”
It’s something you support.

The Bottom Line

Your metabolism doesn’t need fixing.
It needs respect.

When you stop chasing quick fixes and start building muscle, fueling your body, and training with intention, your metabolism responds. Steadily and sustainably.
That’s the long game.
And it works.


Meet Amy Karas

Hi, I’m Amy Karas—coach, mom, and believer in grit built over time. I help women cultivate durable strength through smart, compassionate training. After years coaching diverse women, I saw how many were under-served by one-size-fits-all fitness—especially those with autoimmune conditions or shifting seasons like postpartum or perimenopause. Refinery Strength Collective was born to change that.

Creds & Lived Insight:
  • NASM-CPT, Girls Gone Strong L1
  • Specialty: Autoimmune-aware, female physiology, power development
  • Philosophy: Faith-forward, science-driven, client-led
Values:
  • Dignity First – You are not your diagnosis or decade.
  • Evidence & Empathy – Data + lived experience guide us.
  • Progress Over Perfection – We refine; we don’t punish.
Photo of Amy Karas