Why Under-Eating and Over-Training Feel the Same to Your Body | Refinery Strength Collective

Refinery Strength Collective  ·  November 2026  ·  Week 2

Why Under-Eating
and Over-Training
Feel the Same
to Your Body.

Your body does not know the difference between a calorie deficit and a double workout week and a hard month at work. It just sees stress. And it responds accordingly.


Evidence-Based · Nervous System · November 2026

Every November I watch the same thing happen. Women try to get ahead of the holidays by doing more and eating less at the same time. They add an extra workout. They cut back on food. They stay up late to get everything done. And then they wonder why they feel exhausted, why they are not making progress, and why their body seems to be working against them. Here is what is actually going on.

Your body has one stress system. It does not sort stress into neat categories. Hard workout. Not enough food. Deadline at work. Bad night of sleep. Your body treats all of those things the same way. It releases the same hormone. It triggers the same response. And when all of those things pile up at once, the effects multiply.

1 Stress system shared by all types of stress
cortisol The hormone your body releases in response
compounding How stress stressors interact when stacked

The mechanismWhat Cortisol Actually Does

Cortisol is your stress hormone. In short bursts, it is useful. It helps you react quickly. It gives you energy to handle a threat. Short-term cortisol is a tool your body has always used to survive.

The problem is when cortisol stays elevated for days or weeks at a stretch. Chronically high cortisol tells your body it is in danger. Your body responds to that by holding onto fat, especially around your midsection. It breaks down muscle tissue for energy. It disrupts sleep. It slows digestion. It raises blood sugar and drives cravings for sugar and simple carbs.

None of those things feel like progress. But they are not random. They are your body doing exactly what it evolved to do: conserving resources and bracing for a long hard stretch.

Under-eating is a stressor. Over-training is a stressor. Holiday overwhelm is a stressor. Your body does not rank them. It just counts them.

The patternHow Stress Stacking Works

Here is a common scenario that happens every November and December. You look at the calendar, see how busy the next six weeks will be, and decide to get serious about your training. You add a workout. You cut your calories because you want to get ahead of holiday eating. You are sleeping a little less to get things done. And you are more stressed at work and home than you were in October.

Any one of those things on its own might be manageable. Stack three or four of them together, and your body's total stress load crosses a line. When that happens, your nervous system shifts into what researchers call a state of overreaching or overtraining, depending on how long it persists. Your body stops responding the way it should to training. You stop making progress. You might actually go backward.

What Gets Stacked During the Holidays
Layer 1 Training volume increases because you want to "get ahead"
Layer 2 Calorie intake drops because you are trying to offset holiday food
Layer 3 Sleep quality decreases due to social events and late nights
Layer 4 Work and family demands are at their highest of the year
Result Your body cannot tell the difference between training stress and life stress. Total load exceeds what recovery can handle. Progress stalls. Fatigue rises.

The research backs this up. Studies on overtraining syndrome show that the physical signs of doing too much in the gym look almost identical to the physical signs of chronic life stress. Elevated resting heart rate. Persistent fatigue. Disrupted sleep. Mood changes. Decreased performance. Your body does not care which bucket the stress came from.

The signsHow to Know If You Are in This Pattern

The tricky thing about stress stacking is that it often feels like a motivation problem. You think you just need to push harder. You tell yourself you are being lazy. But the signs of an overloaded system are pretty specific, and they are different from regular tiredness or a bad week.

Signals Worth Paying Attention To

You feel more tired after training than before

A workout should leave you tired but capable. If you are feeling significantly worse two or three hours after a session, your body does not have the resources to recover from the work you are asking it to do.


Your strength is dropping even though you are training more

More training does not always mean more results. When recovery cannot keep up with volume, performance drops. If your numbers are going down when you are training harder, that is your body telling you something.


You are waking up at 3 or 4 in the morning and cannot get back to sleep

This is a classic sign of elevated cortisol. Your body releases cortisol in the early morning hours, but when cortisol is chronically high, that early release wakes you up before you have finished sleeping. It is uncomfortable and it makes everything worse.


You are craving sugar and simple carbs more than usual

High cortisol drives blood sugar dysregulation, which creates strong cravings for fast energy. If you find yourself wanting sweets constantly, that is often a cortisol signal, not a willpower failure.


Everything feels harder than it should

When your system is overloaded, workouts that used to feel manageable feel brutal. Tasks that used to feel easy feel heavy. That shift is real. It is not in your head. It is biology.


You feel good during the holiday season with your current training load

This is the goal. Not burning out in November so you can coast through December on fumes. If your current load feels sustainable, that is exactly right.

What to do insteadTraining Smart Through the Holidays

Here is the counterintuitive truth: the best thing you can do for your fitness during the holidays is do less, not more. Maintain the muscle you have built. Keep your nutrition from going off the rails completely. Prioritize sleep wherever you can. Trust that a sustainable November and December will set you up far better for January than a burned-out crash.

This is what I tell my clients every year. The holidays are not a crisis. They are a season. You do not need to earn your holiday meals. You do not need to punish yourself before or after them. You need to keep training consistently, eat enough to support the work, and give your body enough rest to actually recover.

What this looks like in practice

During the holiday stretch, I ask my clients to do three things. First, keep their training sessions but do not add more. Two or three solid sessions per week is plenty. Second, keep their protein intake up even when everything else gets messy. Protein is your muscle insurance. Third, sleep. It sounds simple. It is hard in November and December. But sleep is when your body does its repair work. Short-changing sleep short-changes your results.

Under-eating during this time makes all of it harder. When you are not eating enough, cortisol goes up to compensate. Your body treats low food availability as a survival signal. Add training stress on top of that, and add holiday life stress on top of that, and you have a system that is grinding instead of adapting.

You are not weak for feeling this way. You are not lacking motivation. You are a human nervous system that has hit a load threshold. Recognizing it is half the work. The other half is making a different choice than your first instinct, which is to push harder.

The goal through the holidays is not transformation. The goal is maintenance. Maintenance is harder than it sounds and more valuable than you think.

The bigger pictureWhy This Matters All Year, Not Just in November

Stress stacking is not just a holiday problem. It happens any time life gets heavy and your instinct is to add more training and eat less food at the same time. Any big work project. Any family crisis. Any period of poor sleep. These are all times when your training prescription needs to change, not because you are not tough enough, but because your body's recovery resources are already spoken for somewhere else.

Good coaching accounts for life. I do not just look at what you did in the gym. I look at how much sleep you are getting, how much you are eating, and what else is going on. All of that matters. Your body is always keeping score of the total load. We should be too.

Next week I am getting personal. I will take you inside what meet prep actually looks like at 37, training with Hashimoto’s, and what happened two weeks into my first block with a new coach. What training has looked like. What humbled me. What I learned anyway. If you have ever thought about competing or just wondered what that kind of training looks like from the inside, this one is for you.

Until then, take care of yourself. Eat your fuel. Get your sleep. Keep showing up.

See y'all,
Amy, Refinery Strength Collective

Research Behind This Post
Meeusen R, Duclos M, Foster C, et al. Prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of the overtraining syndrome: joint consensus statement of the European College of Sport Science and the American College of Sports Medicine. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise. 2013;45(1):186-205. doi.org/10.1249/MSS.0b013e318279a10a
Sapolsky RM. Why Zebras Don't Get Ulcers. 3rd ed. New York: Holt Paperbacks; 2004. (Foundational text on chronic stress physiology and the HPA axis response.)
Epel ES, McEwen B, Seeman T, et al. Stress and body shape: stress-induced cortisol secretion is consistently greater among women with central fat. Psychosomatic Medicine. 2000;62(5):623-632. doi.org/10.1097/00006842-200009000-00005


0 Comments

Leave a Comment


Meet Amy Karas

Hi, I’m Amy Karas—coach, mom, and believer in grit built over time. I help women cultivate durable strength through smart, compassionate training. After years coaching diverse women, I saw how many were under-served by one-size-fits-all fitness—especially those with autoimmune conditions or shifting seasons like postpartum or perimenopause. Refinery Strength Collective was born to change that.

Creds & Lived Insight:
  • NASM-CPT, Girls Gone Strong L1
  • Specialty: Autoimmune-aware, female physiology, power development
  • Philosophy: Faith-forward, science-driven, client-led
Values:
  • Dignity First – You are not your diagnosis or decade.
  • Evidence & Empathy – Data + lived experience guide us.
  • Progress Over Perfection – We refine; we don’t punish.
Photo of Amy Karas